Why Having an “Open-Door Policy” Doesn’t Always Work — Recognition Series | Part 3

Talent Plus Talent Plus

January 21, 2021 Culture Engagement Articles

Series Part: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4

This is the third installment in a series of how to recognize employees in a meaningful way, even during a pandemic.  

When employees are working from home, it is imperative to encourage open and frequent conversations to head off disengagement. In addition to encouraging dialogue, be proactive in soliciting your team members’ input and ideas. Engage in regular one-on-one conversations so you can query them about their unique motivations, aspirations and work preferences and inquire about their ongoing career goals and progress. This will assist you in identifying potential work satisfaction issues before they surface. 

Universally, managers I work with say, “I have an open-door policy; my employees can come and talk with me whenever they want to.” However, many employees will not walk through your open door. If dialogue is so important, then why doesn’t an employee just talk to you when they have an issue? It’s a matter of talent or lack of it.

Talent Plus interviews tell you if an individual is going to speak up, or if you, as their leader or manager, need to reach out to them. Employees who have strong communication skills will respond to your open-door policy, whereas those who are more introverted or shy or who prefer to avoid conflict will probably not. Therefore, if you know an employee is doing great work, yet you sense they are disgruntled about something, simply ask them, “What’s up?” 

Don’t be surprised if you need to dig a little to find out why a person seems distant. When my wife and I first started dating 41 years ago, my tendency was to “run” whenever we had a disagreement – sound familiar? Thank goodness she took the time to coach me to talk about it because it turned out that communication is actually one of my strengths. I can’t stand it if I feel someone is upset with me, so I have learned to utilize communication to reach out and solve whatever issue exists. Especially if the challenge is with someone you care about (or someone who is a highly valuable employee or client), the resolution of conflict is imperative to keeping that relationship strong.  

To learn more about our solutions, contact Talent Plus today at 1.800.VARSITY or visit www.talentplus.com. Scientifically validated, structured interviews and online assessments tell us not only if an individual has the potential to be successful in a specific role, but how the employee can create the most value. 

Series Part: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Talent Plus

Talent Plus

Talent Plus is a team of industry experts who collaborate to deliver insightful and impactful content. Our blogs are designed to provide practical advice and fresh perspectives, helping you stay informed and ahead of the curve.

Latest Posts: Blog

new leader at work

Blog June 05, 2026

How to Successfully Lead Former Peers After a Promotion 

Learn how to go from peer to leader with six smart strategies that will help you make the transition with confidence and ease.

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More
people making goals at work

Blog March 24, 2026

Make 2026 Goals Stick: How Talent Turns Intentions Into Outcomes 

Learn how when people understand their natural talents and leaders coach with those talents in mind, goal execution becomes more realistic. 

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More

Blog March 06, 2026

Reese Witherspoon Is Right About Talent: Here’s Why It Matters for Your Organization 

Learn the importance of building systems that discover, measure and develop talent intentionally across your entire organization. 

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More
Someone managing up and down

Blog February 02, 2026

Managing Up and Down: Using Talent to Strengthen Every Working Relationship

Managing up and down is one of the most valuable skills you can have. Learn how understanding talent can make managing in both directions much easier.

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More

Blog November 04, 2025

Top Performers, Explained: Karl Giuseffi’s Blueprint to Thrive

Explore insights from Karl Giuseffi on how talent science enhances workplace success and team performance.

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More
a manager giving feedback at work

Blog October 22, 2025

Practical Ways to Give Feedback That Strengthens Talent and Growth

Learn how to give good feedback that inspires and builds trust among your team while enhancing their natural strengths.

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More