Are You Really Ready for That Promotion?

Kim Turnage Kim Turnage

December 20, 2017 Blog Leadership

You want to be a rising star in your company, but your meteoric rise can peter out, literally, if you get Peter Principled. The Peter Principle states that people get promoted to their level of incompetence because their promotions are based on their performance in the current role, instead of on their potential to excel in the next role.

To keep growing on a steep trajectory and avoid getting stalled out by the Peter Principle, find ways to start taking on some of the responsibilities of the next level and see how they fit with your strengths before you ask for that promotion. Here’s a checklist of things you can be doing to ‘try on’ the next level and see how it fits:

  • Ask questions that push your team beyond the status quo.
  • Constantly learn and talk with your manager about how new ideas connect to bigger picture goals.
  • Manage change and conflict to keep everyone on track and achieving goals.
  • Take on projects that stretch you into new areas of learning and responsibility.
  • Lead a team of your coworkers in a project that improves results for your team as a whole.

These kinds of activities will give you an opportunity to start performing at the level of the next role so you and your manager can assess your readiness and potential for it. You don’t need permission to start doing these things. Just start doing them.

You are at the greatest risk for being Peter Principled if your next promotion will transition you from individual performer to supervisor or manager. In that leap, you’ll become responsible for achieving goals through capitalizing on other people’s strengths, not just through your own effort. Here are some questions you can ask to see how naturally you’re already working at the next level:

  • Who is already following you? Where do you have influence even though you don’t have formal power or authority?
  • Do you elevate the game and inspire your teammates to work harder and reach higher?
  • How often do you see what other people do well and position them to succeed?
  • How many people naturally turn to you for answers or advice or a listening ear?
  • Does your manager trust you implicitly?

So…are you really ready for that promotion? If you are, aggressively pursue that growth – even if it means going to another company. If reading this casts light on areas for further growth, consider your greatest strengths, and figure out how you can use them to help you improve in those areas.

Latest Posts: Blog

new leader at work

Blog June 05, 2026

How to Successfully Lead Former Peers After a Promotion 

Learn how to go from peer to leader with six smart strategies that will help you make the transition with confidence and ease.

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More
people making goals at work

Blog March 24, 2026

Make 2026 Goals Stick: How Talent Turns Intentions Into Outcomes 

Learn how when people understand their natural talents and leaders coach with those talents in mind, goal execution becomes more realistic. 

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More

Blog March 06, 2026

Reese Witherspoon Is Right About Talent: Here’s Why It Matters for Your Organization 

Learn the importance of building systems that discover, measure and develop talent intentionally across your entire organization. 

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More
Someone managing up and down

Blog February 02, 2026

Managing Up and Down: Using Talent to Strengthen Every Working Relationship

Managing up and down is one of the most valuable skills you can have. Learn how understanding talent can make managing in both directions much easier.

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More

Blog November 04, 2025

Top Performers, Explained: Karl Giuseffi’s Blueprint to Thrive

Explore insights from Karl Giuseffi on how talent science enhances workplace success and team performance.

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More
a manager giving feedback at work

Blog October 22, 2025

Practical Ways to Give Feedback That Strengthens Talent and Growth

Learn how to give good feedback that inspires and builds trust among your team while enhancing their natural strengths.

Talent Plus Talent Plus

Read More